Posts

A THIRD #FRAPNEVER APPEALS TIMETABLE IN 3 MONTHS!

 On 22 February 2023, Minister Creecy issued her third appeals timetable in as many months! Does she and her staff even know what they said the previous month? And to Parliament? They are literally just making it up as they go along. And she continues to insist that she has completed the shark demersal appeals and yet there is simply no record of these appeals, anywhere! The third revised appeals timetable is as follows: The phases and anticipated finalisation dates for each phase is as follows ( verbatim from the Minister's press statement of 22 February 2023 ): Phase one of the appeals process, which was completed on 2 December 2022, dealt with the appeals in the demersal shark sector, the KwaZulu-Natal crustacean trawl sector and with miscellaneous and non-compliant appeals. [ Neither the appeal decisions for shark demersal or the "miscellaneous and non-compliant appeals" have been published some 85 days later] Phase two of the appeals process is presently under consid...

ITS ONLY FEBRUARY AND CREECY'S ALREADY DUMPED HER 5-PHASE APPEALS TIMETABLE!

Yep, that's right! Less than 50 days since publishing her "5-phase appeals process" statement on 15 December 2022, the fisheries minister, Barbara Creecy, summarily dumped her appeals process timetable when she addressed parliament at the beginning of February 2023!  And she did not have the slightest decency to even explain why she is dumping a committed timetable that was less than 50 days old!  Her "old" 15 December 2022 appeals timetable can be read here . We have detailed the many lies Creecy and her Fisheries DDG, Sue Middleton, told Parliament on our twitter timeline which can be accessed here . Creecy's "new" unofficial timetable stated before Parliament now commits to the finalisation of only the traditional line fish appeals by February 2023. She had previously committed to finalising all the tuna pole and south coast rock lobster appeals by February 2023. Now, she seems have delayed those to "October 2023". Maybe. Perhaps. Actu...

PROVISIONAL HAKE INSHORE TRAWL APPEAL DECISIONS: ANOTHER LEGAL TRAVESTY IS UNVEILED

ON 15 DECEMBER 2022, Minister Creecy issued her provisional appeal decisions in the Hake Inshore Trawl fishery. The provisional decisions are a consequence of the Minister losing a review application brought by Hacky Fishing earlier in 2022.  On 26 September 2022, the Western Cape High Court reviewed and set aside the Minister's appeal decisions pertaining to her decisions concerning the evaluation and scoring of 4 other Category B new entrant appellants concerning their respective scores allocated for "vessel access/ownership".  In short, the Minister's original appeal decisions with respect to how she evaluated and scored the appellants on "vessel access/ownership" was determined as being inconsistent, arbitrary and unlawful.  The Minister re-scored 5 appellants, reducing the vessel access/ownership scores to zero for 3 appellants (Cape Fish Processors CC, Zimele Fishing Enterprises CC & Ocean Ukhozi Fishing (Pty) Ltd), confirming Hacky Fishing's z...

#FRAPFAILURE: AN APPEALS PROCESS IN TURMOIL

On 15 December 2022, the Fisheries Minister, Barbara Creecy, issued her first ever statement on the status of the #FRAPFAILURE appeals process. MORE THAN 5 MONTHS AFTER THE APPEALS PROCESS CLOSED AND 15 DAYS BEFORE THE END OF THE FIRST YEAR OF THE ALLOCATED FISHING RIGHTS . To say that the process is mired in turmoil is an understatement. The appeal decisions in the tiny KZN Prawn Trawl fishery demonstrate the extent of the unlawfulness and the lack of basic understanding of the economic structure of a really small fishery. But we should not be surprised that the Minister's decisions are fraught with illegality and a failure to understand the most rudimentary facts about fishing. The people advising her clearly are egregiously out of their depths.  Consider the already successfully reviewed Category B sector appeal decisions in the hake inshore trawl fishery where Hacky Fishing again successfully reviewed and set aside another Ministerial decision. Creecy has now issued a provision...

KZN PRAWN TRAWL APPEAL DECISIONS : THE DESTRUCTION OF YET ANOTHER FISHERY

On 10 December 2022, the Minister published her appeal decisions in the KZN Prawn Trawl fishing sector, even though her appeal record is dated 5 November 2022. It is inexplicable and unprecedented that the Minister sat on this decision for over a month before she decided to communicate her decisions.  The Minister decided to allocated the 1 unit of effort available to her on appeal to a Category C appellant, which scored lower than a competing Category B appellant, after she took into account certain criteria which included transformation and ignored the respective appellant's scores. There is precedent from the Western Cape High court that a minister taking such considerations into account (and ignoring the scoring) is ultra vires and reviewable.  The Minister's decision to allocate the 1 right on appeal to Thalassa Investment (Pty) Ltd is therefore reviewable in our view .  However, ignoring the incredibly pedestrian analysis of the appeals filed in this fishery (coupl...

90 Days Later and Not a Word on the Appeals Process

So more than 3 months have now passed since the closure of the 2022 fishing rights appeals process and Barbara Creecy, the fisheries minister, has embarrassingly failed to say a word about the finalisation (if ever) of this process. Hardly surprising though.  Frap 2022 is an unmitigated and unsalvageable #FRAPFAILURE.  The first fishing season of the FRAP 2022 is effectively done. Those who lost their fishing rights (and who may hope to regain it) will effectively have been denied an entire season of fishing, income and performance. They will forever remain at a disadvantage when compared to those who secured their rights on 28 February 2022. And what makes the failure to decide these appeals timeously even more egregious, is the arrogant silence by the Fisheries Minister, Barbara Creecy. She simply refuses to address the SA fishing community and commit to dates by when appeal decisions will be issued. Perhaps this is because the legal advice she has received to date is that t...

Where are the Appeal Reports, Minister Creecy?

Applicants for commercial fishing rights under Fishing Rights Allocation Process 2021/2022 were required to file their respective administrative appeals in terms of section 80 of the Marine Living Resources Act, 18 of 1998 (“the MLRA”), read with regulation 5 of GN Regulation 1111 of 2 September 1998 (“the Fisheries Regulations”) by 29 July 2022. Regulation 5(3) of the Fisheries Regulations provides as follows: “(3) The appeal contemplated in sub-regulation (2) shall be served by the appellant on the person against whose decision the appeal is made, and that person shall submit a report on the appeal to the minister within 30 days after the appeal had been served on him or her." As such, regulation 5(3) obligates each delegated authority to produce the appeal reports within 30 days after the appeals were filed. That 30-day period expired on 30 August 2022. The obligation is peremptory.  So where are these appeal reports? They should have been made available to all applicants and a...