Posts

Fisheries Management by Exemption: Is this the New Rule?

On 15 December 2014 and again on 10 February 2015, a select group of members of the South African fishing industry were invited to meetings with the Fisheries Department and the Fisheries Minister where the industry was briefed on issues afflicting the management of our commercial and small-scale fishery sectors. The meeting on 10 February 2015 was led by the Fisheries Minister himself but was held a mere 18 days before the expiry of ten-year fishing rights in the high-value, capital intensive tuna long line fishery.  At the 10 February 2015 meeting the Fisheries Minister announced that “… he will exempt all right holders whose rights are due to expire in 2015 from section 18(1) of the Act.”  The Minister further stated in his press statement that “[t]his exemption will grant an extension for a period of one year.” The facts are however quite different. The only fishery that will benefit from a 12 month "extension" is the tuna long line fishery. The majority of f...

DAFF Determines Abalone 2014/2015 TAC

The Fisheries Department (DAFF), led by its Deputy Director-General and the Chief Directors of Research, Fisheries Management and Compliance met with representatives of the SA Abalone industry today (1 December 2014) and confirmed that a decision has been taken to set the 2014-2015 abalone TAC at 96 tons.  The 96 ton allocation is substantially less than the 160 tons motivated for by the industry in a detailed motivation of more than 15 pages. However, the meeting was brief but extremely productive with the DDG, Mr Mortimer Mannya, making it plain that he and his management team intend managing fisheries such as abalone very differently to the past. Mr Mannya emphasised the need for increased collaboration, information sharing and partnerships to be built between industry and his management team. Mr Mannya was nonetheless frank and to the point about his obligations of having to determine the TAC by striking a balance between the scientific advice provided to him and the requi...

Annual International Review of South African Fisheries Commences in Cape Town

The Annual International Stock Assessment Review Workshop focussing on Hake and penguins commenced today at the University of Cape Town. The Annual Review Workshop will conclude on Friday 5 December. The Workshop is open to all interested persons.  Six leading international fisheries scientists arrived in Cape Town this past weekend to conduct an annual review of the analyses used to provide scientific advice for the management of South Africa’s major fisheries.  Starting on 1 December 2014, the review workshop, which is funded by the Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries and the National Research Foundation, takes place at the University of Cape Town and concludes with a presentation by the six-member panel of their findings and recommendations at 15h30 on Friday, 5 December 2014. The scientists making up the review panel are:  • Alistair Dunn (National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research, New Zealand); • Jason Link (National Mari...

Minister's Decision on Red Steenbras is Irrational & Nonsensical

The North Gauteng High Court on 24 November 2014 handed down one of the most important judgements in recent times concerning the determination of catch allowances. The application was brought by, inter alia , the Border Deep Sea Angling Association against the Fisheries Department (DAFF) and its Minister.  The Association sought to review and set aside a 23 November 2012 decision by the Minister to ban all harvesting of red steenbras by recreational fishers. The Association contended that the decision was, inter alia , irrational, taken arbitrarily and capriciously and one that no reasonable person in the position of a minister would take.  The court agreed with the Association, reviewed and set aside the red steenbras ban in so far as it concerns recreational fishers and awarded costs against DAFF and the Minister.  The full judgement is available from Feike on request. The judgement however provides a crucial precedent and standard for the determination of ...